Real Estate Prices in Cayey
Based on 380 active listings on CoquíList. Updated daily.
Active listings
380
87 for rent · 292 for sale
Median rent
$749/mo
Average rent: $1,106/mo
Median sale price
$195,000
Average sale price: $1,219,375
Median rent per sqft
$0.99/sqft
Median sale price per sqft
$114.54/sqft
Rent by number of bedrooms in Cayey
| Bedrooms | Median rent | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| 1 bedroom | $600/mo | 22 |
| 2 bedrooms | $650/mo | 15 |
| 3+ bedrooms | $1,200/mo | 43 |
As of 2026, the median rent in Cayey is $749/mo across 87 rental listings, while the median sale price is $195,000 across 292 homes for sale. These live figures, computed daily from active CoquíList listings, help renters and buyers gauge the Cayey real estate market before making a move.