Supreme Court to decide whether Puerto Rico nurses can practice without joining the Colegio: appeal filed October 27
CoquiList · With information from El Vocero

Puerto Rico's Supreme Court will weigh whether the island's nurses can practice their profession without being forced to belong to the Colegio de Profesionales de la Enfermería. The appeal was filed on October 27, 2026, and the news surfaced this week, following an appellate ruling that, if it stands, would change a rule in place for more than half a century 1.
What happened
On August 28, 2026, a panel of the Court of Appeals declared compulsory membership for nursing professionals unconstitutional. The panel reversed the San Juan trial court, which had sided with the Colegio 23. The lawsuit was filed on October 9, 2025: a nurse, Keyshla Figueroa Ceara, argued that being forced to join and fund the Colegio violated her right not to associate, and other professionals later joined her 34.
The Colegio announced the same day as the ruling that it would go to the Supreme Court 2. The case now reaches the island's highest court, while the attorneys defending the appellate decision, Joel Andrews Cosme Morales, Beverly Joan Marie Chaparro González and Héctor Omar Rivera Vale, prepare their position 1.
Key facts
- The law at issue: Law No. 82 of 1973, which created the Colegio and requires membership to practice 15.
- Provisions struck down: the appeals court declared Articles 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 unconstitutional to the extent they impose mandatory membership, dues, proof of membership, actions to block practice without joining, and sanctions for practicing without belonging 3.
- Panel: Ricardo Marrero Guerrero (author), Lersy Boria Vizcarrondo and Juan Robles Adorno 3.
- Reasoning: the court applied strict scrutiny to freedom of association. It accepted that the state has a compelling interest in regulating nursing and protecting public health, but found a less restrictive alternative: the Junta Examinadora de Enfermería, which Law 254-2015 gives broad powers 3.
- What the Junta does: it licenses, recertifies, adopts regulations and an ethics code, investigates, holds hearings and can discipline or revoke licenses, none of which depends on the professional being a Colegio member 3.
- The Colegio survives: the ruling does not abolish it; it could operate with voluntary membership 13.
Cosme Morales put it this way: "La libertad de asociación no constituye una concesión del Estado" (freedom of association is not a concession of the State) 1.
Background
The debate is not new. In 2024, the Supreme Court ruled on a similar challenge involving another profession's college (2024 TSPR 58), a precedent the parties are likely to invoke 5. This time the justices must decide whether state regulation through the Junta is enough to protect the public without forcing anyone to belong to a professional college.
What it means for you
If you are a nurse or a student about to be licensed, the outcome matters for your wallet and your license. For now, the appellate ruling removes membership, dues and proof of membership as conditions to practice, according to the decision 3. But the case is not final: the Colegio appealed and the Supreme Court has not set a date to hear or decide it 1. There is no clear public information on whether the ruling is in effect while the appeal is pending, so do not stop complying with what the Colegio or your employer currently requires without confirming first.
If you are a patient or a patient's relative, nothing changes in the quality of care: licensing, recertification and discipline are functions of the Junta Examinadora, not of the Colegio 3.
How to / Checklist
- Verify your license status and recertification requirements directly with the Junta Examinadora de Enfermería, attached to the Department of Health (salud.pr.gov; main line 787-765-2929) 6.
- Before you stop paying dues or omit a membership certification, ask the Colegio and your employer's human resources office in writing what they require while the appeal lasts.
- Keep copies of your current license, dues receipts and any communication on the matter.
- If you worry about your particular situation, seek advice from a labor attorney or your union, if you have one.
- Follow the case through the Judiciary (poderjudicial.pr) and notices from the Junta and the Colegio to learn when the Supreme Court sets a schedule.
- If the Colegio is part of your professional network (continuing education, benefits, representation), ask what services it would keep under voluntary membership.
What's next
The next step is for the Supreme Court to decide whether to take the case and set a briefing schedule and, eventually, oral argument. No decision date has been announced 1. The outcome could affect how other regulated professions in Puerto Rico justify mandatory membership, especially after the 2024 precedent 5. Meanwhile the Colegio must show that its role justifies compulsory affiliation, or prepare to survive as a voluntary-membership organization.
Sources
CoquiList summary and local context. Read the linked sources for the original reporting.
Ask about this story
Ask anything about this article — in English or Spanish.
Log in to ask about this story.
Comments (0)
Log in to join the conversation.
No comments yet — be the first.






